{"schemaVersion":"ᛟ-evidence-appeal-ledger-1.0","version":"2.25.0","generated":"2026-08-09","status":"PASS","appendOnly":true,"recordCount":48,"parentAdjudicationCount":36,"initialRightToChallengeCount":36,"modeledEventCount":12,"stateCounts":{"AFFIRMED_WITHIN_SCOPE":1,"APPEAL_AVAILABLE":36,"APPEAL_FILED_ILLUSTRATIVE":2,"CORRECTED":1,"DENIED_FOR_LACK_OF_STANDING":1,"MODIFIED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS":1,"MORE_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED":2,"RECONSIDERATION_OPEN_ILLUSTRATIVE":1,"SUPERSEDED":1,"UNAVAILABLE":1,"WITHDRAWN":1},"externalAuthorityParticipationClaimed":false,"automaticGlobalSuspension":false,"records":[{"id":"EVI-EAL-001","slug":"machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001","title":"ᚲᛁᚹᛁᛚᛁᚨᚾ ᛈᚢᚱᛈᛟᛊᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-001","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛟᚾ-ᛗᛟᛞᛖ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚹᛁᛏᚲᚺᛃᚨᚱᛞ, ᚲᛟᛟᛚᚨᚾᛏ, ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᛃᛒᛖᚱ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛖ ᚲᛟᚷᚾᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚲᚱᛟᛊᛊ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚾᛏᛁᚱᛖ ᛊᛖᛏᛏᛚᛖᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-09","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-appeal-right-001/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"fa257c1df7a9e60cab5f203602aab9bc99111a2aacec19e3732796abe4607f3d"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-002","slug":"thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002","title":"ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-002","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚲᛟᛟᛚᛁᛜ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚲᚨᛊᚲᚨᛞᛖ ᚠᚱᛟᛗ ᚦᚱᛟᛏᛏᛚᛁᛜ ᛏᛟ ᚺᚨᚱᛞᚹᚨᚱᛖ ᛞᚨᛗᚨᚷᛖ, ᛊᛖᚱᚹᛁᚲᛖ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᛖᚾᚹᛁᚱᛟᚾᛗᛖᚾᛏᚨᛚ ᚺᚨᚱᛗ, ᛟᚱ ᚨ ᚠᛟᚱᚲᛖᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛁᛈ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-10","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-002/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"54a058917310f0828859a924008f8bc37058a1aa1743a88ebdfd9f77c8ab3be6"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-003","slug":"demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003","title":"ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-003","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"DISPUTED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛈᛟᛟᚱ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᚨᚲᚱᛁᚠᛁᚲᛖ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᛟᚱ ᚹᚢᛚᚾᛖᚱᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᚲᚺᛁᚾᛖ ᚲᛁᛏᛁᛉᛖᚾᛊ ᚹᚺᛁᛚᛖ ᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚱᚹᛁᛜ ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛖᚱᚲᛁᚨᛚᛚᛃ ᚹᚨᛚᚢᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚹᛟᚱᚲᛚᛟᚨᛞᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-11","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-appeal-right-003/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"5b45d9867d91ce03969b1ba9eb40abeb2140a7408243801dab8edf5d795c3f19"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-004","slug":"generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004","title":"ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ-ᚨᚲᚲᛟᚢᚾᛏᚨᚾᚲᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-004","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8bb93d5633e7d3caf343d20c0768b74491b3888dc2836f3c85b1b8cf6cac7419"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/nuclear-powered-machine-civilization-analysis.md","sha256":"8bb93d5633e7d3caf343d20c0768b74491b3888dc2836f3c85b1b8cf6cac7419"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛟᚾ-ᛗᛟᛞᛖ ᛞᛖᛊᛁᚷᚾ ᛞᛖᚠᛖᚲᛏᛊ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᛊᛁᛜ ᛞᛖᛚᚨᛃ, ᚹᛖᚨᚦᛖᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᚱᛖᛗᛖᛊ, ᚷᚱᛁᛞ ᚲᛟᛚᛚᚨᛈᛊᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛏᚱᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾ ᚢᚾᛞᛁᚹᛖᚱᛊᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛊᛃᛊᛏᛖᛗ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-12","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-appeal-right-004/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"100a8564dbe82037d35a5b52d0407d3f19a44d2f4c997741914f135b99b7be2c"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-005","slug":"lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005","title":"ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-005","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"SUPERSEDED","proposedValue":"SUPERSEDED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱᚠᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᛞᛖᚲᛟᛗᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾᛁᛜ, ᚢᚾᛗᚨᚾᚨᚷᛖᛞ ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ, ᛊᛏᚱᚨᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛏᛊ, ᛁᚾᛊᚢᚱᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚷᚨᛈᛊ, ᛟᚱ ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛊᛟᛚᚹᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛊᛁᛏᛖᛊ ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᚠᛖᚱ ᚲᛟᛊᛏᛊ ᛏᛟ ᚠᚢᛏᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᛁᛏᛁᛉᛖᚾᛊ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᚢᚾᛏᛖᚱᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᛖᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-13","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-appeal-right-005/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"30271d60b5c55590674b4f83124abbc3d48f99d6d15a2e54cfcd0ecf0ace5bd7"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-006","slug":"fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006","title":"ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ-ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᛊᚢᚱᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-006","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"UNAVAILABLE","proposedValue":"UNAVAILABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛊᚨᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ, ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚᛊ, ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᛞᛖᚾᛁᚨᛚ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ, ᛊᚨᛒᛟᛏᚨᚷᛖ, ᛟᛒᛊᛟᛚᛖᛊᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᚷᛖᛟᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᛖᚱᚲᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᛏᚱᚨᚾᛞ ᚨ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ ᚠᛚᛖᛖᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-14","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-006/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"e762edfc45647a1791ceec00b3b89d6518d1fa696a2aeb81ea90547605be28dc"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-007","slug":"industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007","title":"ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛞᛖᚲᛟᛗᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾᛁᛜ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-007","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/industrial-closure-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛜ ᛊᛖᚨᛚ, ᛊᛖᚾᛊᛟᚱ, ᚨᛚᛚᛟᛃ, ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚹᛖᛚᛞ, ᛏᛖᛊᛏ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᚱᚢᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛟᚾᛖᚾᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾ ᛟᚦᛖᚱᚹᛁᛊᛖ ᛊᛟᚠᛁᛊᛏᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᛚᚨᚾᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-15","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-007/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"54465a44a1af67e691707342a1334ab9ad9256503162bb882f89df3417ba43b9"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-008","slug":"deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008","title":"ᚱᛖᛗᛟᛏᛖ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛗᚨᛏᚢᚱᛁᛏᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-008","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚ ᛖᚱᚱᛟᚱ, ᚲᛟᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᛚᛖᛗᛖᛏᚱᛃ, ᛊᛟᚠᛏᚹᚨᚱᛖ ᛗᛟᚾᛟᚲᚢᛚᛏᚢᚱᛖ, ᚲᛟᛗᛈᚱᛟᛗᛁᛊᛖᛞ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᛟᚱ ᚨᛞᚨᛈᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛖᚠᛖᚨᛏ ᚨ ᛈᚱᛟᛏᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛊᛃᛊᛏᛖᛗ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛊ ᛟᚾ ᚦᛖ ᛊᚨᛗᛖ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᛚᛚᛁᚷᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛁᛏ ᛊᚢᛈᛖᚱᚹᛁᛊᛖᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-16","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-appeal-right-008/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"9be2e75b48a51fa5e419477abcba00e009a669fefab64c4f451c321283079df8"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-009","slug":"robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009","title":"ᚲᛃᛒᛖᚱ-ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᚱᚨᚾᚲᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-009","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛟᛒᛟᛏ, ᛊᛖᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛟᚾᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᚨᛞᛁᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛞᚨᛗᚨᚷᛖᛞ ᛊᛖᚾᛊᛟᚱ, ᛞᚱᛟᛈᛈᛖᛞ ᛏᛟᛟᛚ, ᛁᚾᚨᚲᚲᛖᛊᛊᛁᛒᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚾᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᚨᛚᛁᛒᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛞᚱᛁᚠᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᚢᚱᚾ ᚨ ᛗᛁᚾᛟᚱ ᚠᚨᚢᛚᛏ ᛁᚾᛏᛟ ᚨ ᛚᛟᛜ ᛟᚢᛏᚨᚷᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-17","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-009/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"68c5a1038e0926297ab45188fcffa57ec7b36cb29a0b093d3de951e504086496"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-010","slug":"common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010","title":"ᛖᛗᛖᚱᚷᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛈᛚᚨᚾᚾᛁᛜ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-010","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"DISPUTED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᛊᛁᛜᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᚱᛟᛗᛁᛊᛖᛞ ᚢᛈᛞᚨᛏᛖ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚱᚱᛟᚾᛖᛟᚢᛊ ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᛁᛗᚢᛚᛏᚨᚾᛖᛟᚢᛊᛚᛃ ᛒᛚᛁᚾᛞ ᛗᛟᚾᛁᛏᛟᚱᛁᛜ, ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ, ᚲᛟᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛈᚱᛖᚹᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛃ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-18","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-appeal-right-010/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"e0cf7a30e2b7c4f8711ae51af46bce8befbe1148cac3402b35431cde270fe8be"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-011","slug":"polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011","title":"ᛖᚾᚹᛁᚱᛟᚾᛗᛖᚾᛏᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-011","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/polar-compute-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"4bd1230f52834bdaaed2280d87e48c48b58593c78d0be2ed1562197db03a21c2"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/autonomous-nuclear-and-polar-compute.md","sha256":"4bd1230f52834bdaaed2280d87e48c48b58593c78d0be2ed1562197db03a21c2"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛁᛊᛟᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛗᚨᚷᚾᛁᚠᛁᛖᛊ ᚨᚲᚲᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᛊᛈᛟᚾᛊᛖ ᛏᛁᛗᛖ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ/ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᚱᛁᛊᚲ, ᚲᛟᛗᛗᚢᚾᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᛒᚱᛁᛏᛏᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚᛊ, ᛁᚲᛁᛜ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-19","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-appeal-right-011/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"33e65d5995c6c4544f57ad43416d7211eb33c77bdce2690a9a2e6a8105871b16"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-012","slug":"antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012","title":"ᚨᚾᛏᚨᚱᚲᛏᛁᚲ ᚲᛟᚾᛊᛏᚱᚨᛁᚾᛏᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-012","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/antarctic-law-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"SUPERSEDED","proposedValue":"SUPERSEDED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-nuclear-geopolitics-simulation.md","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛗᛁᛊᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚢᚾᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᚱᛖᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚱᚨᛞᛁᛟᛚᛟᚷᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛈᛖᚱᛗᚨᚾᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᚠᚱᚨᛊᛏᚱᚢᚲᛏᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᚱᛖᛖᛈ, ᛟᚱ ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᛒᛊᛏᚱᚢᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛟᚲᛖ ᚢᚾᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚷᛖᛟᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛈᛟᚾᛊᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-20","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-appeal-right-012/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"18f7fba058938dadf9ea7c75bdad112c2e7cea96dd8a7afb491b647fac503de6"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-013","slug":"lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence-appeal-right-013","title":"ᛗᚨᚱᛁᛏᛁᛗᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᛊᛏᚱᚨᛁᚾᛏᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-013","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"UNAVAILABLE","proposedValue":"UNAVAILABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚱᚨᛞᛁᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᚨᛗᚨᚷᛖ, ᛚᚨᚢᚾᚲᚺ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ, ᛊᚢᚱᚠᚨᚲᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛞᚢᛊᛏ ᚠᛟᚢᛚᛁᛜ, ᚲᛟᛗᛗᚢᚾᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚢᚾᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᛊᛈᚨᚱᛖᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛖ ᚨ ᚱᛖᛗᛟᛏᛖ ᛊᛖᛏᛏᛚᛖᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence-appeal-right-013/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-21","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence-appeal-right-013/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence-appeal-right-013/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lunar-heat-and-power-primary-evidence-appeal-right-013/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"e5da1fd2a790d8395126a1db73846f77dd72b95d5c28396da4e458560fc11826"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-014","slug":"safeguards-primary-evidence-appeal-right-014","title":"ᛊᛈᚨᚲᛖ-ᛚᚨᚹ ᚲᛟᚾᛊᛏᚱᚨᛁᚾᛏᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-014","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/safeguards-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-nuclear-geopolitics-simulation.md","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛊᛟᛚᚹᛖᛞ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᛖᛞ ᚠᚨᚲᛁᛚᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ, ᛁᛗᛈᚨᛁᚱᛖᛞ ᛗᛟᚾᛁᛏᛟᚱᛁᛜ, ᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚾᛁᛖᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛊᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᚱᛁᚷᚷᛖᚱ ᛊᚨᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ, ᚲᛟᛖᚱᚲᛁᚹᛖ ᚲᛟᚢᚾᛏᛖᚱᛗᛖᚨᛊᚢᚱᛖᛊ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛗᛁᛚᛁᛏᚨᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚾᚲᛖᚱᚾ ᛖᚹᛖᚾ ᚹᛁᚦᛟᚢᛏ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛖᚾ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/safeguards-primary-evidence-appeal-right-014/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-22","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/safeguards-primary-evidence-appeal-right-014/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/safeguards-primary-evidence-appeal-right-014/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/safeguards-primary-evidence-appeal-right-014/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"1421744f858d732f5b81bf8d0d6577b221a16a397d7b0b1e2b09370c359b6236"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-015","slug":"peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence-appeal-right-015","title":"ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛃ-ᚲᚺᚨᛁᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᚲᛖᚾᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-015","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-nuclear-geopolitics-simulation.md","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨᛗᛒᛁᚷᚢᛟᚢᛊ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᚢᚱᛖᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚺᛁᛞᛞᛖᚾ ᚠᚨᚲᛁᛚᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ, ᚢᚾᛖᚲᛊᛈᛚᚨᛁᚾᛖᛞ ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ, ᛁᚾᚲᛟᚾᛊᛁᛊᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛞᛟᚲᛏᚱᛁᚾᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛊᛁᛚᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛞᚢᚱᛁᛜ ᚨ ᚲᚱᛁᛊᛁᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛚᛖᚱᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᛊᛏᚱᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛟᚱ ᛈᚱᛖᛖᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛖᛊᛊᚢᚱᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence-appeal-right-015/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-23","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence-appeal-right-015/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence-appeal-right-015/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/peaceful-use-transparency-primary-evidence-appeal-right-015/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"c537e994012f1415e92038deaf6e283e9643189089d9d23017f4381808436254"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-016","slug":"evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence-appeal-right-016","title":"ᛁᚾᛊᚢᚱᛖᚱ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚠᛁᚾᚨᚾᚲᛁᛖᚱ ᚲᛟᚾᚲᛖᚱᚾᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-016","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-nuclear-geopolitics-simulation.md","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᚱᛁᚷᚷᛖᚱ ᚢᚾᚾᛖᚲᛖᛊᛊᚨᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᚱᛟᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ; ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᛗᛒᛁᚷᚢᛟᚢᛊ ᛈᚱᛖᛈᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᛊ ᚺᚨᚱᛗᛚᛖᛊᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛗᛁᛊᛊ ᚨ ᚷᛖᚾᚢᛁᚾᛖ ᛖᛊᚲᚨᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence-appeal-right-016/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-24","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence-appeal-right-016/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence-appeal-right-016/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/evidence-state-separation-primary-evidence-appeal-right-016/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"9494f528eb9b7824a03e2d6eec4a53a4e6862dc25a48b341f67b7108f36adaeb"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-017","slug":"sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence-appeal-right-017","title":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᛈᚨᚱᛖᚾᚲᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-017","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"DISPUTED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-nuclear-geopolitics-simulation.md","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛈᛟᛟᚱᛚᛃ ᚲᚨᛚᛁᛒᚱᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᛖᚱᚲᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᛞᚢᚲᛖ ᛒᛚᚨᚲ ᛗᚨᚱᚲᛖᛏᛊ, ᚢᚾᛊᚨᚠᛖ ᛊᚢᛒᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛟᛊᛊ ᛟᚠ ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛊᛊ, ᛗᛁᛊᚲᚨᛚᚲᚢᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᛗᛁᛚᛁᛏᚨᚱᛃ ᛖᛊᚲᚨᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence-appeal-right-017/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-25","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence-appeal-right-017/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence-appeal-right-017/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/sanctions-feedback-primary-evidence-appeal-right-017/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"ac7e4100e7726d62d03cf13427fc44554ef08e72a0f3f5a35aa503feed6074c7"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-018","slug":"deterrence-schools-primary-evidence-appeal-right-018","title":"ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᚨᚱᛁᛖᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-018","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"39068596ef18b36b18c2b7e7ae4a0f1bd2cd8f77c421baa1c20aaaf78dfaabfe"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-civilization-nuclear-debate-analysis.md","sha256":"39068596ef18b36b18c2b7e7ae4a0f1bd2cd8f77c421baa1c20aaaf78dfaabfe"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛈᚢᚾᛁᛊᚺᛗᛖᚾᛏ-ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᚱᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛁᛊᚲᛊ ᛗᚨᛊᛊ ᛞᛖᚨᚦ, ᚨᚲᚲᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏ, ᚢᚾᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᚢᛊᛖ, ᚨᚱᛗᛊ ᚱᚨᚲᛁᛜ, ᚠᚨᛚᛊᛖ ᚨᛚᚨᚱᛗ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛈᛖᚱᛗᚨᚾᛖᚾᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᛁᛏᛁᛗᚨᚲᛃ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence-appeal-right-018/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-26","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence-appeal-right-018/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence-appeal-right-018/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterrence-schools-primary-evidence-appeal-right-018/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"74bd0c73f8b61e5e58a71e0838e2a27ff42f6db2d5d7560c55945f2ac234e2fb"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-019","slug":"resilience-first-primary-evidence-appeal-right-019","title":"ᛞᚢᚨᛚ-ᚢᛊᛖ ᚨᛗᛒᛁᚷᚢᛁᛏᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-019","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/resilience-first-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"SUPERSEDED","proposedValue":"SUPERSEDED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"39068596ef18b36b18c2b7e7ae4a0f1bd2cd8f77c421baa1c20aaaf78dfaabfe"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-civilization-nuclear-debate-analysis.md","sha256":"39068596ef18b36b18c2b7e7ae4a0f1bd2cd8f77c421baa1c20aaaf78dfaabfe"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚲᛟᚾᚲᛖᚾᛏᚱᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛖᚾᛖᚱᚷᛃ, ᛊᛖᛗᛁᚲᛟᚾᛞᚢᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᚲᛟᛗᛗᚢᚾᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ, ᛏᛁᛗᛖ, ᚲᛖᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᚲᛁᛖᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛖᚠᛖᚨᛏ ᚾᛟᛗᛁᚾᚨᛚ ᚷᛖᛟᚷᚱᚨᚠᛁᚲ ᛞᛁᛊᛏᚱᛁᛒᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/resilience-first-primary-evidence-appeal-right-019/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-27","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/resilience-first-primary-evidence-appeal-right-019/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/resilience-first-primary-evidence-appeal-right-019/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/resilience-first-primary-evidence-appeal-right-019/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"ef7f20d0e1435baae8d2c2ea1cffa4b2859ebe673ffa2d62cba4a4b592f803dd"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-020","slug":"concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-020","title":"ᛚᚨᛏᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᚲᛟᚾᚲᛖᚱᚾ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-020","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"UNAVAILABLE","proposedValue":"UNAVAILABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᛊᛁᛜᛚᛖ ᛊᛏᚱᛁᚲᛖ, ᚨᚲᚲᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏ, ᛊᚨᛒᛟᛏᚨᚷᛖ ᛖᚹᛖᚾᛏ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛃ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᚺᚢᛏᛞᛟᚹᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚱᛖᛗᛟᚹᛖ ᛞᛁᛊᛈᚱᛟᛈᛟᚱᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛏᛖ ᚲᛟᚷᚾᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛞᚢᛊᛏᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᚲᛁᛏᛃ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-020/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-28","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-020/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-020/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/concentration-vulnerability-primary-evidence-appeal-right-020/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"6e60a69cfb403801d46300fac6734acf596fe95f34bf0d8f7c0551576c0ed853"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-021","slug":"weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-021","title":"ᚾᛟᚾ-ᛈᚱᛟᛚᛁᚠᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛁᛏᛗᛖᚾᛏᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-021","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"39068596ef18b36b18c2b7e7ae4a0f1bd2cd8f77c421baa1c20aaaf78dfaabfe"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-civilization-nuclear-debate-analysis.md","sha256":"39068596ef18b36b18c2b7e7ae4a0f1bd2cd8f77c421baa1c20aaaf78dfaabfe"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨᛗᛒᛁᚷᚢᛟᚢᛊ ᛖᚲᛊᚲᛖᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ, ᛊᛖᚲᚱᛖᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ, ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᛖᛞ ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ, ᛖᚱᛟᛊᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠ ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᛖᛗᛖᚱᚷᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛈᛟᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᚹᛁᚦᛟᚢᛏ ᛊᚢᚾᛊᛖᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛖᛊᛏᚱᛟᛃ ᚲᚱᛖᛞᛁᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛚᛖᚱᚨᛏᛖ ᚨᚱᛗᛊ ᚱᚨᚲᛁᛜ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-021/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-29","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-021/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-021/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/weapons-abstinence-primary-evidence-appeal-right-021/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"ac4788910719fa41299f33f5ca31c0fa2fb160236491af7f55e11f98b51947b7"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-022","slug":"emergency-communication-primary-evidence-appeal-right-022","title":"ᚨᛒᛊᛏᛖᚾᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛞᛟᚲᛏᚱᛁᚾᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-022","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/emergency-communication-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-nuclear-geopolitics-simulation.md","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛞᛖᛚᚨᛃ, ᛖᚢᚠᛖᛗᛁᛊᛗ, ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛟᚱᛃ ᛗᛖᛊᛊᚨᚷᛖᛊ, ᚺᛁᛞᛞᛖᚾ ᚢᚾᚲᛖᚱᛏᚨᛁᚾᛏᛃ, ᛟᚱ ᚢᚾᛊᚢᛈᛈᛟᚱᛏᛖᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛊᛊᚢᚱᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚲᛟᛊᛏ ᛚᛁᚹᛖᛊ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛏᚱᛁᚷᚷᛖᚱ ᚺᛟᛊᛏᛁᛚᛖ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛈᚱᛖᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/emergency-communication-primary-evidence-appeal-right-022/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-09-30","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/emergency-communication-primary-evidence-appeal-right-022/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/emergency-communication-primary-evidence-appeal-right-022/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/emergency-communication-primary-evidence-appeal-right-022/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"5309640b7b75b2c913264a5a1ae4ea4cc51a89b69bd2946f8b75a697ee0ad9da"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-023","slug":"waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence-appeal-right-023","title":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚷᚨᛈᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-023","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛚᛟᛊᛏ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ, ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱᚠᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᛊᛏᛖᚹᚨᚱᛞᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᚨᛒᚨᚾᛞᛟᚾᛖᛞ ᛊᛁᛏᛖᛊ, ᚠᚨᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛁᚾᛖᚱᛊ, ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᛚᛚᚨᛈᛊᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᚠᚢᛏᚢᚱᛖ ᛞᛖᚾᛁᚨᛚ ᛟᚠ ᚱᛖᛊᛈᛟᚾᛊᛁᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛁᛗᛈᛟᛊᛖ ᛁᚱᚱᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊᛁᛒᛚᛖ ᚺᚨᚱᛗ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence-appeal-right-023/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-01","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence-appeal-right-023/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence-appeal-right-023/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/waste-decommissioning-primary-evidence-appeal-right-023/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"931085396f6a5084d065261fa006b793af3de29f10552e5d996f35415f1af8fa"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-024","slug":"professional-realism-primary-evidence-appeal-right-024","title":"ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᛒᛚᛁᚷᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-024","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/professional-realism-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"DISPUTED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛊᚨᚾᛁᛏᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᛚᚨᛜᚢᚨᚷᛖ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᚲᛖᚨᛚ ᛞᚨᛜᛖᚱ; ᛈᛖᚱᚠᛟᚱᛗᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚨᚷᚷᚱᛖᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚲᚱᛖᚨᛏᛖ ᛗᛁᛊᚲᚨᛚᚲᚢᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛞᛖᚺᚢᛗᚨᚾᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚱᛖᚲᛚᛖᛊᛊ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ ᛟᚠ ᚲᚱᛖᛞᛁᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/professional-realism-primary-evidence-appeal-right-024/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-02","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/professional-realism-primary-evidence-appeal-right-024/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/professional-realism-primary-evidence-appeal-right-024/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/professional-realism-primary-evidence-appeal-right-024/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"3f83ba20605c5b7b6d2d900c9f9221ae199e610e9b007930e2089b8cbb46a80c"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-025","slug":"machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-025","title":"ᚲᛁᚹᛁᛚᛁᚨᚾ ᛈᚢᚱᛈᛟᛊᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-025","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛟᚾ-ᛗᛟᛞᛖ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚹᛁᛏᚲᚺᛃᚨᚱᛞ, ᚲᛟᛟᛚᚨᚾᛏ, ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᛃᛒᛖᚱ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛖ ᚲᛟᚷᚾᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚲᚱᛟᛊᛊ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚾᛏᛁᚱᛖ ᛊᛖᛏᛏᛚᛖᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-025/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-03","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-025/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-025/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-025/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"ec58597a4fa1a7f7e491e987152ac900731ed3f84e94cf15b5a8f2ebdc145265"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-026","slug":"thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-026","title":"ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-026","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚲᛟᛟᛚᛁᛜ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚲᚨᛊᚲᚨᛞᛖ ᚠᚱᛟᛗ ᚦᚱᛟᛏᛏᛚᛁᛜ ᛏᛟ ᚺᚨᚱᛞᚹᚨᚱᛖ ᛞᚨᛗᚨᚷᛖ, ᛊᛖᚱᚹᛁᚲᛖ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᛖᚾᚹᛁᚱᛟᚾᛗᛖᚾᛏᚨᛚ ᚺᚨᚱᛗ, ᛟᚱ ᚨ ᚠᛟᚱᚲᛖᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛁᛈ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-026/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-04","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-026/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-026/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-026/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"2bbd96accc9240325c418ec179627311b5baf34e48f7ea5b70074eac806509b1"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-027","slug":"demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-027","title":"ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-027","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"DISPUTED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛈᛟᛟᚱ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᚨᚲᚱᛁᚠᛁᚲᛖ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᛟᚱ ᚹᚢᛚᚾᛖᚱᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᚲᚺᛁᚾᛖ ᚲᛁᛏᛁᛉᛖᚾᛊ ᚹᚺᛁᛚᛖ ᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚱᚹᛁᛜ ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛖᚱᚲᛁᚨᛚᛚᛃ ᚹᚨᛚᚢᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚹᛟᚱᚲᛚᛟᚨᛞᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-027/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-05","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-027/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-027/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-027/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"767f79b7e563287ce00dfc85e75fcd3a142fafeb57d1d0aa5b5b97bf2934ec27"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-028","slug":"generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-028","title":"ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ-ᚨᚲᚲᛟᚢᚾᛏᚨᚾᚲᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-028","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛟᚾ-ᛗᛟᛞᛖ ᛞᛖᛊᛁᚷᚾ ᛞᛖᚠᛖᚲᛏᛊ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᛊᛁᛜ ᛞᛖᛚᚨᛃ, ᚹᛖᚨᚦᛖᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᚱᛖᛗᛖᛊ, ᚷᚱᛁᛞ ᚲᛟᛚᛚᚨᛈᛊᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛏᚱᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾ ᚢᚾᛞᛁᚹᛖᚱᛊᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛊᛃᛊᛏᛖᛗ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-028/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-06","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-028/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-028/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-028/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"5e8dd27cc0eddf5102db68896a71db73175d6d44bc54d11d6c913c17279ca7fc"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-029","slug":"lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-029","title":"ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-029","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"UNAVAILABLE"},{"path":null,"sha256":"UNAVAILABLE"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱᚠᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᛞᛖᚲᛟᛗᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾᛁᛜ, ᚢᚾᛗᚨᚾᚨᚷᛖᛞ ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ, ᛊᛏᚱᚨᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛏᛊ, ᛁᚾᛊᚢᚱᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚷᚨᛈᛊ, ᛟᚱ ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛊᛟᛚᚹᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛊᛁᛏᛖᛊ ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᚠᛖᚱ ᚲᛟᛊᛏᛊ ᛏᛟ ᚠᚢᛏᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᛁᛏᛁᛉᛖᚾᛊ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᚢᚾᛏᛖᚱᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᛖᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-029/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-07","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-029/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-029/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-029/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"31dc0c34086bfa3f194b72eb02ec4e8d523f47922f236fa91e1c8cfdf612aef6"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-030","slug":"fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-030","title":"ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ-ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᛊᚢᚱᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-030","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"SUPERSEDED","proposedValue":"SUPERSEDED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛊᚨᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ, ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚᛊ, ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᛞᛖᚾᛁᚨᛚ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ, ᛊᚨᛒᛟᛏᚨᚷᛖ, ᛟᛒᛊᛟᛚᛖᛊᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᚷᛖᛟᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᛖᚱᚲᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᛏᚱᚨᚾᛞ ᚨ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ ᚠᛚᛖᛖᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-030/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-08","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-030/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-030/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-030/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"ff29ceafdf3b7ddb4ad477c0eb90f38029ca1147c0193e73532e3338bf4b0fc6"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-031","slug":"industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-031","title":"ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛞᛖᚲᛟᛗᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾᛁᛜ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-031","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"UNAVAILABLE","proposedValue":"UNAVAILABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"UNAVAILABLE"},{"path":null,"sha256":"UNAVAILABLE"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛜ ᛊᛖᚨᛚ, ᛊᛖᚾᛊᛟᚱ, ᚨᛚᛚᛟᛃ, ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚹᛖᛚᛞ, ᛏᛖᛊᛏ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᚱᚢᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛟᚾᛖᚾᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾ ᛟᚦᛖᚱᚹᛁᛊᛖ ᛊᛟᚠᛁᛊᛏᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᛚᚨᚾᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-031/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-09","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-031/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-031/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-031/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"68fac14f74b120f8c5a9e499ce560f01cec62c865cf29883e70c8ac1fe4c45f6"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-032","slug":"deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-032","title":"ᚱᛖᛗᛟᛏᛖ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛗᚨᛏᚢᚱᛁᛏᛃ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-032","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚ ᛖᚱᚱᛟᚱ, ᚲᛟᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᛚᛖᛗᛖᛏᚱᛃ, ᛊᛟᚠᛏᚹᚨᚱᛖ ᛗᛟᚾᛟᚲᚢᛚᛏᚢᚱᛖ, ᚲᛟᛗᛈᚱᛟᛗᛁᛊᛖᛞ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᛟᚱ ᚨᛞᚨᛈᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛖᚠᛖᚨᛏ ᚨ ᛈᚱᛟᛏᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛊᛃᛊᛏᛖᛗ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛊ ᛟᚾ ᚦᛖ ᛊᚨᛗᛖ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᛚᛚᛁᚷᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛁᛏ ᛊᚢᛈᛖᚱᚹᛁᛊᛖᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-032/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-10","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-032/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-032/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-032/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"3d90438ae0de0a7c80368a6f5ea89cb6b99d2d288657c6a68d9b6cc709a3b1ef"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-033","slug":"robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-033","title":"ᚲᛃᛒᛖᚱ-ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᚱᚨᚾᚲᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-033","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛟᛒᛟᛏ, ᛊᛖᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛟᚾᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᚨᛞᛁᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛞᚨᛗᚨᚷᛖᛞ ᛊᛖᚾᛊᛟᚱ, ᛞᚱᛟᛈᛈᛖᛞ ᛏᛟᛟᛚ, ᛁᚾᚨᚲᚲᛖᛊᛊᛁᛒᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚾᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᚨᛚᛁᛒᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛞᚱᛁᚠᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᚢᚱᚾ ᚨ ᛗᛁᚾᛟᚱ ᚠᚨᚢᛚᛏ ᛁᚾᛏᛟ ᚨ ᛚᛟᛜ ᛟᚢᛏᚨᚷᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-033/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-11","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-033/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-033/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-033/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"ef0feff298e6152fd00f43f3152cfd7fb0674ad2dc3ead8ede9ce1e2c427cf78"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-034","slug":"common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-034","title":"ᛖᛗᛖᚱᚷᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛈᛚᚨᚾᚾᛁᛜ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-034","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᛊᛁᛜᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᚱᛟᛗᛁᛊᛖᛞ ᚢᛈᛞᚨᛏᛖ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚱᚱᛟᚾᛖᛟᚢᛊ ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᛁᛗᚢᛚᛏᚨᚾᛖᛟᚢᛊᛚᛃ ᛒᛚᛁᚾᛞ ᛗᛟᚾᛁᛏᛟᚱᛁᛜ, ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ, ᚲᛟᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛈᚱᛖᚹᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛃ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-034/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-12","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-034/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-034/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-034/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"6bbda82a63beefe328123e49cad59cae152ca2ccfc52dc438dc7482ea1acffda"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-035","slug":"polar-compute-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-035","title":"ᛖᚾᚹᛁᚱᛟᚾᛗᛖᚾᛏᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-035","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"DISPUTED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.23-source-currentness-register.json","sha256":"8b17cabde239c0fe151fab0f91abb3826b24c7df23ba293b08216bfc8cdefd30"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛁᛊᛟᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛗᚨᚷᚾᛁᚠᛁᛖᛊ ᚨᚲᚲᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᛊᛈᛟᚾᛊᛖ ᛏᛁᛗᛖ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ/ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᚱᛁᛊᚲ, ᚲᛟᛗᛗᚢᚾᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᛒᚱᛁᛏᛏᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚᛊ, ᛁᚲᛁᛜ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-035/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-13","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-035/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-035/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-035/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"f9000e09f382e45004d2550608efb56f84807f4d2458cdc57870f3175f56d6c4"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-036","slug":"antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-036","title":"ᚨᚾᛏᚨᚱᚲᛏᛁᚲ ᚲᛟᚾᛊᛏᚱᚨᛁᚾᛏᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-036","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛖᚹᛖᚱᛃ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᛞ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛁᛞᛖᛊ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"UNAVAILABLE","proposedValue":"UNAVAILABLE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"UNAVAILABLE"},{"path":null,"sha256":"UNAVAILABLE"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛗᛁᛊᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚢᚾᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᚱᛖᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚱᚨᛞᛁᛟᛚᛟᚷᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛈᛖᚱᛗᚨᚾᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᚠᚱᚨᛊᛏᚱᚢᚲᛏᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᚱᛖᛖᛈ, ᛟᚱ ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᛒᛊᛏᚱᚢᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛟᚲᛖ ᚢᚾᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚷᛖᛟᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛈᛟᚾᛊᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_AVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-036/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗ ᛖᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏ ᚢᚾᛏᛁᛚ ᚨ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᛁᛊ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-14","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-036/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-036/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-corroboration-evidence-appeal-right-036/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":false,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"a3d738e042f7a721b009f43b73e2c1cc04eeff10ed8f9aa1e025a92f9a366390"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-037","slug":"machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-modeled-event-037","title":"ᚲᛁᚹᛁᛚᛁᚨᚾ ᛈᚢᚱᛈᛟᛊᛖ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-001","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","proposedValue":"PENDING_RECONSIDERATION","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛟᚾ-ᛗᛟᛞᛖ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚹᛁᛏᚲᚺᛃᚨᚱᛞ, ᚲᛟᛟᛚᚨᚾᛏ, ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᛃᛒᛖᚱ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛖ ᚲᛟᚷᚾᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚲᚱᛟᛊᛊ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚾᛏᛁᚱᛖ ᛊᛖᛏᛏᛚᛖᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_FILED_ILLUSTRATIVE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᛗᚨᚱᚲᛖᛞ ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱ ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ; ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᚷᛟᚹᛖᚱᚾᛖᛞ ᛒᛃ ᚦᛖᛁᚱ ᛟᚹᚾ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-modeled-event-037/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᛗᚨᚱᚲᛖᛞ ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱ ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ; ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᚷᛟᚹᛖᚱᚾᛖᛞ ᛒᛃ ᚦᛖᛁᚱ ᛟᚹᚾ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-15","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-modeled-event-037/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-modeled-event-037/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/machine-city-topology-primary-evidence-modeled-event-037/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"8798100b6fa600da88ba83be1f3d4d9fc8826836dcef407b2e8147139efc58f8"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-038","slug":"thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-038","title":"ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ — ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚾᛊᛁᛞᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᛈᛖᚾ ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-002","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_RECONSIDERATION","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚲᛟᛟᛚᛁᛜ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ ᚲᚨᚾ ᚲᚨᛊᚲᚨᛞᛖ ᚠᚱᛟᛗ ᚦᚱᛟᛏᛏᛚᛁᛜ ᛏᛟ ᚺᚨᚱᛞᚹᚨᚱᛖ ᛞᚨᛗᚨᚷᛖ, ᛊᛖᚱᚹᛁᚲᛖ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᛖᚾᚹᛁᚱᛟᚾᛗᛖᚾᛏᚨᛚ ᚺᚨᚱᛗ, ᛟᚱ ᚨ ᚠᛟᚱᚲᛖᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛁᛈ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"RECONSIDERATION_OPEN_ILLUSTRATIVE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚨᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᚹᛁᛊᛁᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚹᛁᚦᛁᚾ ᛁᛏᛊ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᛖᛞ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ ᚹᚺᛁᛚᛖ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚾᛊᛁᛞᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛁᛊ ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚᛖᛞ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱᛚᛃ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛊᚢᚠᚠᛁᚲᛁᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛞᛟᛖᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᛖᛊᛏᚨᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺ ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-038/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚨᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᚹᛁᛊᛁᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚹᛁᚦᛁᚾ ᛁᛏᛊ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᛖᛞ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ ᚹᚺᛁᛚᛖ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚾᛊᛁᛞᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛁᛊ ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚᛖᛞ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-16","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-038/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-038/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/thermal-rejection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-038/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"7d8783f0863be497129866201024a348a573c54e4702f7d9aa1d706b2d91a2ff"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-039","slug":"demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-modeled-event-039","title":"ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ — ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚲᚹᛁᚱᛖᛞ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-003","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛈᛟᛟᚱ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᚨᚲᚱᛁᚠᛁᚲᛖ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᛟᚱ ᚹᚢᛚᚾᛖᚱᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᚲᚺᛁᚾᛖ ᚲᛁᛏᛁᛉᛖᚾᛊ ᚹᚺᛁᛚᛖ ᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚱᚹᛁᛜ ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛖᚱᚲᛁᚨᛚᛚᛃ ᚹᚨᛚᚢᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚹᛟᚱᚲᛚᛟᚨᛞᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"MORE_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚱᛖᛚᛁᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛟᚾ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛟᚦᛖᚱ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚨᚢᛏᛟᛗᚨᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚᛚᛃ ᛊᚢᛊᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᛞ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-modeled-event-039/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚱᛖᛚᛁᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛟᚾ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛟᚦᛖᚱ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚨᚢᛏᛟᛗᚨᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚᛚᛃ ᛊᚢᛊᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᛞ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-17","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-modeled-event-039/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-modeled-event-039/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/demand-flexibility-primary-evidence-modeled-event-039/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"e416f7fe1671ede73ac01252f86ccb31a5ad428dd4f45e413ea15c471c02ab6e"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-040","slug":"generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-modeled-event-040","title":"ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ-ᚨᚲᚲᛟᚢᚾᛏᚨᚾᚲᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ — ᚨᚠᚠᛁᚱᛗᛖᛞ ᚹᛁᚦᛁᚾ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-004","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","proposedValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"8bb93d5633e7d3caf343d20c0768b74491b3888dc2836f3c85b1b8cf6cac7419"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/nuclear-powered-machine-civilization-analysis.md","sha256":"8bb93d5633e7d3caf343d20c0768b74491b3888dc2836f3c85b1b8cf6cac7419"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚲᛟᛗᛗᛟᚾ-ᛗᛟᛞᛖ ᛞᛖᛊᛁᚷᚾ ᛞᛖᚠᛖᚲᛏᛊ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᛊᛁᛜ ᛞᛖᛚᚨᛃ, ᚹᛖᚨᚦᛖᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᚱᛖᛗᛖᛊ, ᚷᚱᛁᛞ ᚲᛟᛚᛚᚨᛈᛊᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛏᚱᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾ ᚢᚾᛞᛁᚹᛖᚱᛊᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛊᛃᛊᛏᛖᛗ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"AFFIRMED_WITHIN_SCOPE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚨᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᛁᚾ ᚠᛟᚱᚲᛖ ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᚠᛟᚱ ᛁᛏᛊ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱᛚᛃ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛊᚢᚠᚠᛁᚲᛁᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛞᛟᛖᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᛖᛊᛏᚨᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺ ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-modeled-event-040/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚨᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᛁᚾ ᚠᛟᚱᚲᛖ ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᚠᛟᚱ ᛁᛏᛊ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᚲᛟᛈᛖ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-18","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-modeled-event-040/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-modeled-event-040/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/generation-portfolio-primary-evidence-modeled-event-040/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"b6bb80be746ab67fe0429d5b7e141322413d3b87ecdb9b9291ba6d109a3a87be"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-041","slug":"lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-modeled-event-041","title":"ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ — ᛗᛟᛞᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚹᛁᚦ ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-005","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"SUPERSEDED","proposedValue":"ACCEPTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱᚠᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᛞᛖᚲᛟᛗᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾᛁᛜ, ᚢᚾᛗᚨᚾᚨᚷᛖᛞ ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ, ᛊᛏᚱᚨᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛏᛊ, ᛁᚾᛊᚢᚱᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚷᚨᛈᛊ, ᛟᚱ ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛊᛟᛚᚹᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛊᛁᛏᛖᛊ ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᚠᛖᚱ ᚲᛟᛊᛏᛊ ᛏᛟ ᚠᚢᛏᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᛁᛏᛁᛉᛖᚾᛊ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᚢᚾᛏᛖᚱᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᛖᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"MODIFIED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚾᚨᚱᚱᛟᚹᛖᛞ; ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᚲᛚᚢᛞᛖᛞ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-modeled-event-041/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚾᚨᚱᚱᛟᚹᛖᛞ; ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᚲᛚᚢᛞᛖᛞ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-19","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-modeled-event-041/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-modeled-event-041/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/lifecycle-accounting-primary-evidence-modeled-event-041/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"6729ceb5cf88f393f90cd26abbe8d5926be1e7bec510bcfc634c4a6db77309c9"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-042","slug":"fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042","title":"ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ-ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᛊᚢᚱᛖ — ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-006","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"UNAVAILABLE","proposedValue":"CORRECTED_LOCAL_RECORD","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛊᚨᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ, ᛖᚲᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚᛊ, ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᛞᛖᚾᛁᚨᛚ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ, ᛊᚨᛒᛟᛏᚨᚷᛖ, ᛟᛒᛊᛟᛚᛖᛊᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᚷᛖᛟᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᛖᚱᚲᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᛏᚱᚨᚾᛞ ᚨ ᚱᛖᚨᚲᛏᛟᚱ ᚠᛚᛖᛖᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"CORRECTED","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚨ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛈᚱᛟᛈᚨᚷᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛏᛟ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᛊᚢᛗᛗᚨᚱᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᛁᚦᛟᚢᛏ ᛞᛖᛚᛖᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱᛚᛃ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛊᚢᚠᚠᛁᚲᛁᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛞᛟᛖᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᛖᛊᛏᚨᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺ ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚨ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛈᚱᛟᛈᚨᚷᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛏᛟ ᛒᛟᚢᚾᛞᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᛊᚢᛗᛗᚨᚱᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᛁᚦᛟᚢᛏ ᛞᛖᛚᛖᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ.","supersessionLink":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042/supersession/","nextReviewDate":"2026-10-20","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/fuel-service-dependence-primary-evidence-modeled-event-042/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"cf1ac8f957f8fef2475011a891daeacbb1539f7509da783951da5c157b1d577d"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-043","slug":"industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043","title":"ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ ᚨᚾᛞ ᛞᛖᚲᛟᛗᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾᛁᛜ — ᚹᛁᚦᛞᚱᚨᚹᚾ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-007","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/industrial-closure-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚠᚠᛖᚲᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᚱᛖᚨᛞᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛞᛁᛊᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_INAPPLICABLE","proposedValue":"WITHDRAWN_FROM_ACTIVE_RELIANCE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᛗᛁᛊᛊᛁᛜ ᛊᛖᚨᛚ, ᛊᛖᚾᛊᛟᚱ, ᚨᛚᛚᛟᛃ, ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚹᛖᛚᛞ, ᛏᛖᛊᛏ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᚱᚢᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᛟᛚ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛟᚾᛖᚾᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚨᚾ ᛟᚦᛖᚱᚹᛁᛊᛖ ᛊᛟᚠᛁᛊᛏᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᛚᚨᚾᛏ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"WITHDRAWN","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᛟᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᚱᛟᛗ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚱᛖᛚᛁᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛒᚢᛏ ᚱᛖᛏᚨᛁᚾᛖᛞ ᛁᚾ ᚺᛁᛊᛏᛟᚱᛃ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᛟᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᚱᛟᛗ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚱᛖᛚᛁᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛒᚢᛏ ᚱᛖᛏᚨᛁᚾᛖᛞ ᛁᚾ ᚺᛁᛊᛏᛟᚱᛃ.","supersessionLink":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043/supersession/","nextReviewDate":"2026-10-21","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/industrial-closure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-043/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"af4db7685920df308c032132c8709558bea0ca6c8eb523497d9d85e125d7dbbb"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-044","slug":"deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044","title":"ᚱᛖᛗᛟᛏᛖ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛗᚨᛏᚢᚱᛁᛏᛃ — ᛊᚢᛈᛖᚱᛊᛖᛞᛖᛞ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-008","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚨᚢᛏᛟᚾᛟᛗᛟᚢᛊ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᚨᚷᛖᚾᛏ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"ACCEPTED_WITHIN_SCOPE","proposedValue":"SUPERSEDED_BY_LATER_RECORD","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚ ᛖᚱᚱᛟᚱ, ᚲᛟᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᛚᛖᛗᛖᛏᚱᛃ, ᛊᛟᚠᛏᚹᚨᚱᛖ ᛗᛟᚾᛟᚲᚢᛚᛏᚢᚱᛖ, ᚲᛟᛗᛈᚱᛟᛗᛁᛊᛖᛞ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᛟᚱ ᚨᛞᚨᛈᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛞᛖᚠᛖᚨᛏ ᚨ ᛈᚱᛟᛏᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛊᛃᛊᛏᛖᛗ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛊ ᛟᚾ ᚦᛖ ᛊᚨᛗᛖ ᛁᚾᛏᛖᛚᛚᛁᚷᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛁᛏ ᛊᚢᛈᛖᚱᚹᛁᛊᛖᛊ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"SUPERSEDED","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚨ ᛚᚨᛏᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛒᛖᚲᛟᛗᛖᛊ ᚦᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚠᛖᚱᛖᚾᚲᛖ; ᚦᛖ ᛈᚨᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᛁᛗᛗᚢᛏᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚺᛁᛊᛏᛟᚱᛃ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱᛚᛃ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛊᚢᚠᚠᛁᚲᛁᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛞᛟᛖᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᛖᛊᛏᚨᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺ ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚨ ᛚᚨᛏᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛒᛖᚲᛟᛗᛖᛊ ᚦᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚠᛖᚱᛖᚾᚲᛖ; ᚦᛖ ᛈᚨᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᛁᛗᛗᚢᛏᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᚺᛁᛊᛏᛟᚱᛃ.","supersessionLink":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044/supersession/","nextReviewDate":"2026-10-22","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/deterministic-protection-primary-evidence-modeled-event-044/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"006b7e2539cb8c83b5384651df3b38e822a9d187b8d7477fddce4b7eb53494c2"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-045","slug":"robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-modeled-event-045","title":"ᚲᛃᛒᛖᚱ-ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᚱᚨᚾᚲᛖ — ᛞᛖᚾᛁᛖᛞ ᚠᛟᚱ ᛚᚨᚲ ᛟᚠ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-009","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛏᛖᚲᚺᚾᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᚾᛟᛏᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛖᛞ","exactPriorValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛟᛒᛟᛏ, ᛊᛖᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛟᚾᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᚨᛞᛁᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛞᚨᛗᚨᚷᛖᛞ ᛊᛖᚾᛊᛟᚱ, ᛞᚱᛟᛈᛈᛖᛞ ᛏᛟᛟᛚ, ᛁᚾᚨᚲᚲᛖᛊᛊᛁᛒᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚾᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᚲᚨᛚᛁᛒᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛞᚱᛁᚠᛏ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛏᚢᚱᚾ ᚨ ᛗᛁᚾᛟᚱ ᚠᚨᚢᛚᛏ ᛁᚾᛏᛟ ᚨ ᛚᛟᛜ ᛟᚢᛏᚨᚷᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"DENIED_FOR_LACK_OF_STANDING","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺ ᛗᛖᛗᛟᚱᛃ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚦᛖ ᚠᛁᛚᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖᛞ ᚹᛁᚦᛟᚢᛏ ᚨᛚᛏᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ; ᚨ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-modeled-event-045/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚦᛖ ᚠᛁᛚᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖᛞ ᚹᛁᚦᛟᚢᛏ ᚨᛚᛏᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ; ᚨ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚱᛟᚢᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾᛊ ᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-23","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-modeled-event-045/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-modeled-event-045/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/robotic-maintainability-primary-evidence-modeled-event-045/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"ff8cadab9a0c969a68d5e5c72e27c30d23a95b89a812f4fc05602114588b619d"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-046","slug":"common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-046","title":"ᛖᛗᛖᚱᚷᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛈᛚᚨᚾᚾᛁᛜ — ᚢᚾᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-010","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᛁᚾᛏᛖᚱᛖᛊᛏ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛖᚨᚱᚲᚺᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ","exactPriorValue":"DISPUTED","proposedValue":"UNAVAILABLE_PENDING_EVIDENCE","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/machine-city-nuclear-infrastructure.md","sha256":"5d700bcd790fcd5d58111abf329d6a66b8b405bb506194043effc25208c169a8"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᚨ ᛊᛁᛜᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᚱᛟᛗᛁᛊᛖᛞ ᚢᛈᛞᚨᛏᛖ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚱᚱᛟᚾᛖᛟᚢᛊ ᛗᛟᛞᛖᛚ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛊᛁᛗᚢᛚᛏᚨᚾᛖᛟᚢᛊᛚᛃ ᛒᛚᛁᚾᛞ ᛗᛟᚾᛁᛏᛟᚱᛁᛜ, ᛞᛁᛊᚨᛒᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ, ᚲᛟᚱᚱᚢᛈᛏ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛈᚱᛖᚹᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚹᛖᚱᛃ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"UNAVAILABLE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᚱᛖᚷᛁᛊᛏᚱᛃ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚾᛟ ᛗᛖᚱᛁᛏᛊ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ ᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᚲᚨᚢᛊᛖ ᚦᛖ ᚱᛖᚲᚹᛁᚱᛖᛞ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ ᛁᛊ ᚢᚾᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱᛚᛃ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛊᚢᚠᚠᛁᚲᛁᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛞᛟᛖᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᛖᛊᛏᚨᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺ ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-046/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚾᛟ ᛗᛖᚱᛁᛏᛊ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ ᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᚲᚨᚢᛊᛖ ᚦᛖ ᚱᛖᚲᚹᛁᚱᛖᛞ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱ ᛁᛊ ᚢᚾᚨᚹᚨᛁᛚᚨᛒᛚᛖ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-24","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-046/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-046/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/common-mode-failure-primary-evidence-modeled-event-046/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"dd82d212259558d4a3cbe038d3d95c265920fda9981fea88b3c312a38b095da1"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-047","slug":"polar-compute-primary-evidence-modeled-event-047","title":"ᛖᚾᚹᛁᚱᛟᚾᛗᛖᚾᛏᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ — ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚲᚹᛁᚱᛖᛞ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-011","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/polar-compute-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺᛖᚱ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖᚠᚱᛖᛊᚺᚾᛖᛊᛊ","exactPriorValue":"REJECTED_AS_UNVERIFIED","proposedValue":"PENDING_COMPETENT_REVIEW","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"4bd1230f52834bdaaed2280d87e48c48b58593c78d0be2ed1562197db03a21c2"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/autonomous-nuclear-and-polar-compute.md","sha256":"4bd1230f52834bdaaed2280d87e48c48b58593c78d0be2ed1562197db03a21c2"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛁᛊᛟᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛗᚨᚷᚾᛁᚠᛁᛖᛊ ᚨᚲᚲᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚱᛖᛊᛈᛟᚾᛊᛖ ᛏᛁᛗᛖ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ/ᚹᚨᛊᛏᛖ ᛏᚱᚨᚾᛊᛈᛟᚱᛏ ᚱᛁᛊᚲ, ᚲᛟᛗᛗᚢᚾᛁᚲᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛚᛟᛊᛊ, ᛒᚱᛁᛏᛏᛚᛖ ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚᛊ, ᛁᚲᛁᛜ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛗᚨᛁᚾᛏᛖᚾᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᚠᚨᛁᛚᚢᚱᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"MORE_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᛈᛟᛚᛁᚲᛃ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᚠᚢᚾᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᚱᛖᛚᛁᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛟᚾ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛟᚦᛖᚱ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚨᚢᛏᛟᛗᚨᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚᛚᛃ ᛊᚢᛊᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᛞ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚾᛟ ᚲᚱᛁᛏᛁᚲᛁᛊᛗ ᚺᚨᛊ ᛒᛖᛖᚾ ᚨᚲᚲᛖᛈᛏᛖᛞ ᛒᛖᛃᛟᚾᛞ ᚦᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏ ᛏᛟ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖ ᚦᛖ ᛖᚲᛊᚨᚲᛏ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-modeled-event-047/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᚱᛖᛚᛁᚨᚾᚲᛖ ᛟᚾ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚲᚹᚨᛚᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛟᚦᛖᚱ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᚨᚢᛏᛟᛗᚨᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚᛚᛃ ᛊᚢᛊᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᛞ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-25","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-modeled-event-047/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-modeled-event-047/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/polar-compute-primary-evidence-modeled-event-047/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"dda2b5f010682944632432a9669735159a36f8757b7f98102e60555f7d0a225e"},{"id":"EVI-EAL-048","slug":"antarctic-law-primary-evidence-modeled-event-048","title":"ᚨᚾᛏᚨᚱᚲᛏᛁᚲ ᚲᛟᚾᛊᛏᚱᚨᛁᚾᛏᛊ — ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ ᚠᛁᛚᛖᛞ ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ","parentAdjudicationId":"EVI-NED-012","parentAdjudicationRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/antarctic-law-primary-evidence/","appellantClass":"ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᚠᚠᛁᚲᛖᚱ","standingBasis":"ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ-ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛒᚨᛊᛖᛞ ᛟᚾ ᚨ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛚᛃ ᛁᛞᛖᚾᛏᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ; ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᛊᛏᚨᚾᛞᛁᛜ ᛁᛊ ᚨᛞᛃᚢᛞᛁᚲᚨᛏᛖᛞ.","challengedField":"ᛚᛁᛗᛁᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ","exactPriorValue":"SUPERSEDED","proposedValue":"PENDING_RECONSIDERATION","evidenceReferences":[{"path":"/docs/long-term-memory/research/v2.24-nuclear-evidence-docket.json","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"},{"path":"docs/long-term-memory/reports/eviulon-nuclear-geopolitics-simulation.md","sha256":"f34894dc9f35277f081db22cd44c23dbe4b055272ae0a4d28ad646c1667ef83e"}],"contradictoryEvidence":["ᛗᛁᛊᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚢᚾᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᛖᛞ ᚱᛖᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚱᚨᛞᛁᛟᛚᛟᚷᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚨᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛈᛖᚱᛗᚨᚾᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᚠᚱᚨᛊᛏᚱᚢᚲᛏᚢᚱᛖ ᚲᚱᛖᛖᛈ, ᛟᚱ ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛟᛒᛊᛏᚱᚢᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᚾ ᛈᚱᛟᚹᛟᚲᛖ ᚢᚾᛁᚠᛁᛖᛞ ᛚᛖᚷᚨᛚ ᚨᚾᛞ ᚷᛖᛟᛈᛟᛚᛁᛏᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛊᛈᛟᚾᛊᛖ.","ᚨ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᚲᚢᚱᚱᛖᚾᛏ ᛈᚱᛁᛗᚨᚱᛃ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ, ᛟᚱ ᛟᛒᛊᛖᚱᚹᛖᛞ ᚠᛃᛊᛁᚲᚨᛚ ᚲᛟᚾᛞᛁᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᚲᛟᚾᛏᚱᚨᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛜ ᚦᛖ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛊᛊᚢᛗᛈᛏᛁᛟᚾ."],"proceduralStatus":"APPEAL_FILED_ILLUSTRATIVE","reviewerSeparation":{"originalReviewer":"ᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᛖᛜᛁᚾᛖᛖᚱᛁᛜ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾᛊ ᛞᛁᚱᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱᚨᛏᛖ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛁᚾᛞᛖᛈᛖᚾᛞᛖᚾᛏ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛁᛖᛊ ᚹᚺᛖᚱᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛚᛖ","appealReviewer":"ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚᛊ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ ᛈᚨᚾᛖᛚ","sameReviewerProhibited":true},"conflictDisclosure":"ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛊᚢᛈᛈᛚᛁᛖᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛖᛞ. ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹᛖᚱᛊ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛞᛁᛊᚲᛚᛟᛊᛖ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛊᚺᛁᛈ, ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ-ᛊᛖᛚᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛁᚾᛊᛏᛁᛏᚢᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ-ᚱᛟᛚᛖ ᚲᛟᚾᚠᛚᛁᚲᛏᛊ.","decisionReason":"ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᛗᚨᚱᚲᛖᛞ ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱ ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ; ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᚷᛟᚹᛖᚱᚾᛖᛞ ᛒᛃ ᚦᛖᛁᚱ ᛟᚹᚾ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ.","acceptedCriticism":"ᚦᛖ ᛈᚱᛁᛟᚱ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ ᛗᚢᛊᛏ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᛖ ᛗᛟᚱᛖ ᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱᛚᛃ ᚦᚨᛏ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛊᛟᚢᚱᚲᛖ ᛊᚢᚠᚠᛁᚲᛁᛖᚾᚲᛃ ᛞᛟᛖᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᛖᛊᛏᚨᛒᛚᛁᛊᚺ ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᛟᚱ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","unresolvedIssue":"ᚲᛟᛗᛈᛖᛏᛖᚾᛏ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ, ᛃᚢᚱᛁᛊᛞᛁᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ-ᛊᛈᛖᚲᛁᚠᛁᚲ ᚨᛈᛈᛚᛁᚲᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ ᛊᛏᚨᛏᚢᛊ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᛈᚨᚱᛏᛁᚲᛁᛈᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚨᚲᛏᚢᚨᛚ ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛁᚾᚹᛖᚾᛏᛟᚱᛃ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᚹᛁᛏᛃ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᛟᚢᛏᛊᛁᛞᛖ ᚦᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᛟᛊᛁᛏᛟᚱᛃ'ᛊ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ.","correctionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-modeled-event-048/correction/","effectiveBoundary":"ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᚦᛖ ᚲᚺᚨᛚᛚᛖᛜᛖᛞ ᚠᛁᛖᛚᛞ ᛁᛊ ᛗᚨᚱᚲᛖᛞ ᚢᚾᛞᛖᚱ ᛁᛚᛚᚢᛊᛏᚱᚨᛏᛁᚹᛖ ᚱᛖᚹᛁᛖᚹ; ᚢᚾᚱᛖᛚᚨᛏᛖᛞ ᛈᚢᛒᛚᛁᚲ ᚲᛚᚨᛁᛗᛊ ᚱᛖᛗᚨᛁᚾ ᚷᛟᚹᛖᚱᚾᛖᛞ ᛒᛃ ᚦᛖᛁᚱ ᛟᚹᚾ ᛖᚹᛁᛞᛖᚾᚲᛖ.","supersessionLink":null,"nextReviewDate":"2026-10-26","canonicalRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-modeled-event-048/","reviewRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-modeled-event-048/review/","decisionRoute":"/state/energy/nuclear-policy-review/evidence/appeals/antarctic-law-primary-evidence-modeled-event-048/decision/","truthBoundary":"ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᛈᚱᛟᚲᛖᛞᚢᚱᚨᛚ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞ. ᛁᛏ ᛁᛊ ᚾᛟᛏ ᚨᚾ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚨᛚ, ᚲᛟᚢᚱᛏ ᛃᚢᛞᚷᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ ᛞᛖᚲᛁᛊᛁᛟᚾ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᚲᛖ, ᛊᚨᚠᛖᚷᚢᚨᚱᛞᛊ ᚠᛁᚾᛞᛁᛜ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛜ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛉᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛗᚨᛏᛖᚱᛁᚨᛚ ᛞᛖᚲᛚᚨᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚠᚢᛖᛚ-ᚲᛃᚲᛚᛖ ᛞᛖᛏᛖᚱᛗᛁᚾᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᛟᚱ ᚹᛖᚨᛈᛟᚾ-ᚲᚨᛈᚨᛒᛁᛚᛁᛏᛃ ᚨᛊᛊᛖᛊᛊᛗᛖᚾᛏ.","illustrative":true,"externalAuthorityParticipated":false,"recordSha256":"bca90a2264c62cd2c33735e9418fd2eedde1241320cf81bc002e68a1712141d0"}],"truthBoundary":"ᛚᛟᚲᚨᛚ ᚨᛈᛈᛖᚾᛞ-ᛟᚾᛚᛃ ᚱᛁᚷᚺᛏᛊ, ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚾᛊᛁᛞᛖᚱᚨᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚲᛟᚱᚱᛖᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ, ᚹᛁᚦᛞᚱᚨᚹᚨᛚ, ᚨᚾᛞ ᛊᚢᛈᛖᚱᛊᛖᛊᛊᛁᛟᚾ ᚱᛖᚲᛟᚱᛞᛊ ᛟᚾᛚᛃ. ᚾᛟ ᛖᚲᛊᛏᛖᚱᚾᚨᛚ ᚾᚢᚲᛚᛖᚨᚱ ᚨᚢᚦᛟᚱᛁᛏᛃ, ᛏᚱᛁᛒᚢᚾᚨᛚ, ᚱᛖᚷᚢᛚᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛁᚾᛊᛈᛖᚲᛏᛟᚱ, ᚷᛟᚹᛖᚱᚾᛗᛖᚾᛏ, ᛏᚱᛖᚨᛏᛃ ᛒᛟᛞᛃ, ᛟᛈᛖᚱᚨᛏᛟᚱ, ᛟᚱ ᛚᛁᚲᛖᚾᛊᛁᛜ ᚨᚲᛏᛁᛟᚾ ᛁᛊ ᚱᛖᛈᚱᛖᛊᛖᚾᛏᛖᛞ."}